Jedi, Sith, Holy War and the Holy Grail.
- Michael "Richard" MacGregor
- 1 day ago
- 5 min read

Modern people struggle to speak about death without either sentimentality or denial. We alternate between pretending death is nothing and fearing it as total annihilation. Yet one of the most successful modern myths, Star Wars, preserves an older and deeper way of understanding mortality, transcendence, and the human struggle for meaning.
At the center of Jedi teaching is a deceptively simple line: there is no death, there is only the Force. This is not a claim that bodies do not die. It is a symbolic statement about identity, fear, and what ultimately endures. Read carefully, the conflict between Jedi and Sith becomes a map of competing worldviews. Transcendence versus reduction. Surrender versus control. The greater war versus the lesser one.
The Jedi and the Meaning of Death
The Jedi do not deny death. They prepare for it. Their training is not primarily about combat but about discipline of fear, detachment from the ego, and alignment with a higher order. When a Jedi dies, what vanishes is the body and the personal identity bound to it. What remains is that part of the self that was already oriented beyond possession, fear, and domination.
This is why Jedi deaths feel peaceful rather than tragic. Obi Wan steps forward unarmed before Vader not in resignation but in victory. His identity is no longer confined to survival. He has already learned what the Force is meant to teach. Death is not annihilation for one who never mistook the body for the self.
The Sith as a Metaphor for Materialism and Atheism
The Sith represent the opposite metaphysical instinct. They believe there is nothing above the will. The Force is not a sacred order to align with but a resource to be exploited. Power, domination, and extension of life become the highest goods because there is no higher reality to submit to.
This mirrors modern materialism with striking precision. Reality is reduced to matter and force. Meaning is constructed rather than discovered. Power replaces truth. Survival becomes sacred.
If death is total extinction, then it must be resisted at all costs. This is why Sith figures obsess over cheating death through cloning, possession, and artificial immortality. Sith immortality is always grotesque because it is life without transcendence, existence extended without meaning. They fear death not because they love life, but because death would expose the emptiness of a self that never reached beyond control.
Anakin Skywalker and the Fear That Corrupts
Anakin Skywalker does not fall because he is evil. He falls because he cannot surrender.
He loves but clings. He fears loss but seeks power instead of transcendence. He tries to solve a metaphysical problem, mortality, with material force.
This is a modern man in mythic form. When fear of death becomes the organizing principle of life, the result is anxiety, domination, and self-destruction. The dark side is not wickedness for its own sake. It is what happens when survival replaces truth.
Evola and the Greater Holy War
The same insight appears in philosophical language in the work of Julius Evola. Evola distinguished between the lesser war and the greater holy war. The lesser war is external. Politics, enemies, power struggles, and history. The greater war is internal. The struggle against fear, attachment, ego, and the illusion that life is merely biological persistence.
For Evola, death is not annihilation but a test. Most men fear it because their identity is bound to psychology, emotion, and flesh. When those dissolve, nothing remains. The transcendent warrior has shifted his center upward. He stands in a self that was never merely alive and therefore does not collapse when life ends. Immortality in this sense is not automatic. It is earned through orientation.
Christianity and the Defeat of Death
Christianity agrees with the Jedi and with Evola on a crucial point. Clinging to life destroys the soul. But it goes further. Christianity insists that death is real, tragic, and an enemy. Yet it also proclaims that death has been defeated, not escaped. Jesus Christ does not bypass death. He enters it fully and breaks it from within. Resurrection is not survival. It is transformation.
The Christian is not saved by strength of will but by dying to the ego and being raised into a higher life. Where Evola emphasizes standing upright through death, Christianity emphasizes surrender and renewal. Different metaphysics, the same courage demanded.
The Bhagavad Gita and the Warrior Who Transcends Death
An even older expression of this truth appears in the Bhagavad Gita, spoken on a battlefield just before war begins. The warrior Arjuna falters, overwhelmed by fear, doubt, and the weight of death. He is given a command that cuts through sentimentality and despair alike.
If you die, you gain the heavens. If you live, you gain the earth. So, stand up and fight.
This is not a call to bloodlust or nihilism. It is a metaphysical instruction. Arjuna’s crisis is not tactical. It is existential. He is paralyzed by attachment to life, to outcomes, and to fear of loss. The teaching he receives is ruthless in its clarity. Once fear of death is transcended, action becomes free.
The warrior is told to fight not for survival, pleasure, or even victory, but out of duty aligned with a higher order. Whether he lives or dies is secondary. What matters is that he does not collapse inwardly. In this sense, the battlefield is symbolic of the greater war within.
This logic matches everything already traced here. The Jedi act without attachment to outcome, surrendering themselves to the Force. Christianity teaches that the one who loses his life for truth gains it. Evola’s transcendent warrior enters danger having already overcome fear of death. Fearlessness is born from transcendence, not aggression.
The Sith cannot understand this logic. For them, death is total loss, so every action becomes desperate. Power must be seized. Life must be extended. Enemies must be crushed. The Gita’s warrior, the Jedi, and the Christian martyr all reject this premise. They act not because life is everything, but because something higher than life exists.
Once a man no longer measures himself by survival alone, he cannot be spiritually defeated. Death loses its tyranny, and life becomes something to be used rightly rather than clung to
anxiously.
Conclusion
The Greater War and the Grail. All of this points toward an ancient truth hidden beneath modern language. The real battle is not political, biological, or historical. It is interior. The lesser war is fought against enemies outside us. The greater holy war is fought against fear, attachment, and the ego that trembles before death.
This is the war Evola meant. This is where the Holy Grail appears, not as an object to seize but as a realization to be attained. The Grail symbolizes the discovery of a center beyond life and death, a self that does not dissolve when the body falls.
Only the transcendent warrior finds it. The one who has already died inwardly. The one who has overcome himself before confronting mortality. Such a man does not flee death, nor does he worship it. He passes through it intact because his identity was never confined to flesh, fear, or time.
This is why the Jedi can lay down their weapons and walk calmly into death. This is why the Sith must cling, dominate, and decay. This is why Christianity insists that life is only found on the far side of surrender.
To win the greater war is not to live forever, but to become the kind of being for whom death is not defeat. In that victory, the Grail is revealed not as survival and not as power, but as transcendence itself.




